The Gavel Is Decorative
Alexander Muse – A theory has been gathering force on 𝕏 with each new procedural disappointment. The argument goes roughly like this. Vice President JD Vance is president of the Senate. The Senate is failing to deliver. Therefore Vance should stride into the chamber, gavel John Thune aside, fire Elizabeth MacDonough on the spot, force the SAVE America Act to the floor, and rule from the chair that the legislative filibuster is dead.
The frustration animating this theory is entirely legitimate. Republicans hold the White House, the House, and 53 Senate seats, yet the president’s most urgent priorities sit stalled. Anger needs a target. Vance, gavel in hand and presiding over a chamber that refuses to move, is a visible and convenient one.
The theory is also wrong. It is wrong in a specific, structural, and instructive way, and the misunderstanding produces precisely the kind of misdirected political energy that lets the actual obstacles escape accountability. Continue reading →